Law enforcement divided over effectiveness of facial recognition

Is facial recognition technology up to the job, or do we just wish it was? Kirsty McMahon investigates.

There has been a flurry of activity in biometric solutions being employed by the security industry and law enforcement recently, facial recognition in particular. However, the use of existing facial recognition solutions seems to have divided law enforcement professionals. So it is really up to scratch?

It was reported in July that Leicestershire Police had begun a trial with NEC’s facial recognition solution, NeoFace. Results during the trial period have been impressive, with the BBC quoting early tests producing a 45% identification rate, and the force has made the decision to purchase the software and continue using it.

I spoke exclusively to ID Manager Andy Ramsay at Leicestershire Police who told me that the solution has been an amazing addition to the forces arsenal.

Magnificent identification tool
“We were so impressed by the results we saw during the trial of NEC’s NeoFace system that we have purchased the software,” he said. “As an identification tool it is magnificent and we couldn’t be happier with the results. Police forces from across the country have been visiting us to see how the system is performing and we highly recommend it.”

Ramsay explained that the only challenge with the solution is the need for a skilled operator to run the system. However, he said that NEC was very supportive and even extended the trial period to ensure the team was entirely comfortable before purchasing.

In addition, Ramsay accredits a large portion of the success of NeoFace to the high quality of the images stored in Leicestershire Police’s database, which holds 92,000 faces on file.

He said, “All images stored in our database are taken using Northgate software and are very high quality. We believe this is a key factor in how well NeoFace fits into our system.”

What’s the catch?
So it seems that Leicestershire Police think facial recognition technology is up to spec.

DCI Mick Neville at London’s Metropolitan Police agrees, so long as it’s being used in exactly the right situation. He told me that when used at airports, for example, facial recognition often has a success rate of around 95 per cent, but that’s down to the fact that the technology is applied to high quality, head on images.

According to Neville, that’s the catch. The technology available today is reliant on very, very high quality CCTV systems that produce high quality megapixel images. If the angle isn’t face on, if the lighting is poor, if the background isn’t suitable, or the image is poor quality it will not work. Neville pointed out that this situation accounts for the vast majority of surveillance systems currently in use.

“It’s only useful in set ways and in the last 18 months there’s only been about ten reliable identifications from facial recognition systems in the Met,” Neville told me. “This is in comparison to 150 a week from super recognisers. That is a vast difference.”

Super recognisers are officers within the Met with an extraordinary talent for remembering faces. All police forces have officers with these skills, but the Met has identified them and developed a systematic approach to put their talent to use.

It was Neville who was responsible for finding these remarkable people and creating an initiative that has changed the way the Met works. These are not individuals locked in an office in front of a bank of screens; they are out on the front line, working in custody suites or as detectives, continually adding to their database of faces.

Neville set out a clear example of technology’s inability to compete with the Met’s super recognisers in the London Riots. Facial recognition identified just one perpetrator in the riots, while one especially successful super recogniser identified 180.

Unrealistic expectations
“People, particularly in senior police and security positions, have an unrealistic expectation of facial recognition solutions,” said Neville. “They want to believe the technology is further advanced than it is because they are so keen to improve security and success while reducing costs. I think there are potentially situations where facial recognition and super recognisers could be combined effectively. However, as the technology stands today, facial recognition will never replace people. Not only are super recognisers outperforming the technology, the human element and the application of human interpretation is always going to be vital.”

Perhaps a good example of a police force having unrealistic expectations of the capabilities of new technology is Dubai Police. It has been reported by Reuters that Dubai police plan to issue Google Glass hands-free eyewear to its detectives to help them fight crime using facial recognition technology.

A spokesman confirmed to Reuters that software developed by Dubai police would enable a connection between the wearer and a database of wanted people. Once the device ‘recognised’ a suspect based on facial biometric data, it would alert the officer wearing the gadget.

It’s understood that in the first phase, Google Glass would be used to combat traffic violations and track vehicles suspected of involvement in motoring offences. A second phase would see the technology rolled out to detectives, the spokesman said.

However, when I approached Google for comment on this and to find out more about the facial recognition capabilities of Google Glass, a spokesperson told me that Glass does not allow facial recognition apps as per Google’s developers terms of service.

So it would appear that, although futuristic and flashy, this new development in wearable technology may be blocked by Google.

A long way to go
Touchless Biometric Systems (TBS), pioneers in biometric solutions (see related story here), which is leading the way with new finger print technology supports the notion that there is room for improvement when it comes to facial recognition.

Alex Zarrabi, Business Development Director, Middle East, told me, “Existing solutions are a long way from being effective for use with large populations as it generates a lot of false identifications. That’s why we’re working on a patented next generation solution.”

Overall, it appears that although there has been some success with existing facial recognition technology there is a long way to go before we have fully effective solutions at our finger tips that live up to Hollywood’s sci-fi fantasies.

About Security Buyer

Security Buyer is the leading authority in global security content, delivering expert news, in-depth articles, exclusive interviews, and industry insights across print, digital, and event platforms. Published 10 times a year, the magazine is a trusted resource for professionals seeking updates and analysis on the latest developments in the security sector.

To submit an article, or for sponsorship opportunities, please contact our team below.

Rebecca Spayne picture 2025

Rebecca Spayne

Managing
EDITOR

Georgina Turner image

Georgina Turner

Sales
Manager

Afua Akoto image - Security Buyer

Afua Akoto

Marketing Manager

Read the Latest Issue

Follow us on X

Follow us on X

Click Here

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow us on LinkedIn

Click Here

Advertise here

Reach decision makers and amplify your marketing

Advertise here

Click Here

Related News

suprema

Suprema Achieves EN 60839 Certification

Suprema, a global provider of AI-powered access control and security solutions, has achieved EN 60839-11-1:2013 Grade 3 certification
Image Provided by Invixium

Invixium showcases new Biometric Solutions to ISC WEST 2025

Invixium is set to exhibit its latest Enterprise Series biometric solutions at ISC WEST. Making its entry into….
Copyright: Security Buyer

Facial Recognition: Innovation vs. Accountability

Facial recognition technology is advancing with AI, IoT, and privacy-first security, but regulatory compliance, ethical AI, accountability…
Malik Alyousef, Co-founder & COO, Mozn

Mozn Unveils a New Generation of AI Fraud Prevention

FOCAL by Mozn strengthens its Fraud Prevention Suite with Device Fingerprinting, Fraud Analytics, and Fraud Management as a Service…
HID

Trends report finds mobile credentials, biometrics and AI surge

Latest State of Security and Identity Report from HID reveals a shift toward software-driven solutions and artificial intelligence in 2025
Copyright - Security Buyer

What Is an Access Control Entry? The Security Must-Know for 2025

Discover how access control entry secures businesses with mechanical, digital, biometric, and AI-driven solutions, preventing unauthorised…
AA_DAS_PR_ControlID_KingsAward2024_500x300

ASSA ABLOY biometric solution wins major security award

ASSA ABLOY has been recognised at the 25th Kings Excellence Awards. iDFace from Control iD won Best Biometric Product of the Year.
Entrust

Entrust Appoints Key Leaders

Entrust announced the hiring of Michael Klieman as Global Vice President of Product Management for Digital Security Solutions and Parag Patel
Biometrics

A Guide to biometric installation

Rebecca Spayne of Security Buyer provides a comprehensive guide to implementing biometric solutions for security managers, analysing…
Suprema

Suprema Launches CLUe

Suprema has announced the official launch of CLUe, open cloud integration platform designed to make access control easy and secure..
Scroll to Top